Score: 5

"Not great"

submission: WeRBopBop #8

date: April 13, 2008

This was kind of heavy handed. It would be nice if it were a little more clever, or subtle, but oh well.

Score: 7

"Nice"

submission: Nix Timelapse

date: March 28, 2008

I don't think I've seen a "making of" style Flash done this well before. Yet, you are also somewhat noobish for including uncompressed audio. It didn't need to be 6 MBs.

Score: 0

"Spammer..."

submission: The Crap Of Death.

date: March 28, 2008

dei....

Score: 7

"Pretty good"

submission: SeamlessR - Classical Change

date: July 18, 2008

It feels too repetitive sometimes, like there wasn't a good enough reason to repeat a melodic segment one more time. This makes the piece feel longer than it is. More dynamic contrast and varying of voices when repeating sections will help prevent this.

Score: 8

"Cool"

submission: SeamlessR - Drum

date: July 18, 2008

I like the spaces of silence... I don't even know how to write for percussion, lol!

Score: 10

"Great textures"

submission: .X. Rising Symphony

date: March 30, 2008

I really liked how you utilized the full orchestra, in that you didn't throw everything in all at once the whole piece. The piece has a great pulsing feel to it and the notes were placed exactly right. I love the fugal section at 1:18, and I'd be interested in seeing the score, if you wouldn't mind. Good use of unconventional mode at 0:14; is that Lydian you're using?

One criticism, though, is that the ending doesn't seem to work very well. I understand that the piece is just building the whole time, and I think a resolute ending would kill the piece. Instead, it seems like the ending should be the most intense and leading part of the piece. It would help if it were loud.